Paradoxes Of Catholicism
Robert Hugh Benson
20 chapters
3 hour read
Selected Chapters
20 chapters
PARADOXES OF CATHOLICISM
PARADOXES OF CATHOLICISM
_These sermons (which the following pages contain in a much abbreviated form) were delivered, partly in England in various places and at various times, partly in New York in the Lent of 1912, and finally, as a complete course, in the church of S. Silvestro-in-Capite, in Rome, in the Lent of 1913. Some of the ideas presented in this book have already been set out in a former volume entitled "Christ in the Church" and a few in the meditations upon the Seven Words, in another volume, but in altoget
1 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
PARADOXES OF CATHOLICISM INTRODUCTORY
PARADOXES OF CATHOLICISM INTRODUCTORY
(i) JESUS CHRIST, GOD AND MAN I and My Father are one .—JOHN X. 30. My Father is greater than I .—JOHN XIV. 20. The mysteries of the Church, a materialistic scientist once announced to an astonished world, are child's play compared with the mysteries of nature.[1] He was completely wrong, of course, yet there was every excuse for his mistake. For, as he himself tells us in effect, he found everywhere in that created nature which he knew so well, anomaly piled on anomaly and paradox on paradox, a
19 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
I
I
Blessed are the peacemakers; for they shall be called the children of God. —MATT. V. 9. Do not think that I am come to send peace on earth; I came not to send peace but the sword. —MATT. X. 34. We have considered how the key to the Paradoxes of the Gospel and the key to the Paradoxes of Catholicism is one and the same—that the Life that produces them is at once Divine and Human. Let us go on to consider how this resolves those of Catholicism, especially those charged against us by our adversarie
10 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
II
II
Make to yourselves friends of the Mammon of iniquity . You cannot serve God and Mammon .-LUKE XVI. 9, 13. We have seen how the Church of the Prince of Peace must continually be the centre of war. Let us go on to consider how, as a Human Society dwelling in this world, she must continually have her eyes fixed upon the next, and how, as a Divine Society, she must be open to the charge of worldliness. I. (i) The charge is a very common one: "Look at the extraordinary wealth and splendour that this
9 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
III
III
Holy, Holy, Holy! —IS. VI. 3. Christ Jesus came into this world to save sinners_. I TIM. I. 15. A very different pair of charges—and far more vital—than those more or less economic accusations of worldliness and otherworldliness which we have just considered, concern the standards of goodness preached by the Church and her own alleged incapacity to live up to them. These may be briefly summed up by saying that one-half the world considers the Church too holy for human life, and the other half, n
10 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
IV
IV
Rejoice and be exceeding glad…. Blessed are they that mourn .— MATT. V. 12, 5. The Catholic Church, as has been seen, is always too "extreme" for the world. She is content with nothing but a Divine Peace, and in its cause is the occasion of bloodier wars than any waged from merely human motives. She is not content with mere goodness, but urges always Sanctity upon her children; yet simultaneously tolerates sinners whom even the world casts out. Let us consider now how, in fulfilling these two ap
10 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
V
V
Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with thy whole heart … and thy neighbour as thyself .—LUKE x. 27. We have already considered two charges brought against Catholicism from opposite quarters; namely, that we are too worldly and too otherworldly, too much busied with temporal concerns to be truly spiritual, and too metaphysical and remote and dogmatic to be truly practical. Let us go on to consider these same two charges produced, so to speak, a little further into a more definitely spiritual plane
12 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
VI
VI
Whosoever shall not receive the kingdom of God as a little child shall not enter into it .—MARK X. 15. Some things hard to be understood, which the unlearned and the unstable wrest, as also the other Scriptures, to their own perdition .— II PET. III. 16. There are two great gifts, or faculties, by which men attain to truth: faith and reason. From these two sides, therefore, come two more assaults upon the Catholic position, a position which itself faces in both these directions. On the one side
12 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
VII
VII
The truth shall make you free .—JOHN VIII. 32. Bringing into captivity every understanding to the obedience of Christ .—II COR. X. 5. We have already considered in outline the relations between Faith and Reason; how each, in its own province, is supreme and how each, in its turn, supports and ratifies the other. We pass on to a development of that theme, springing almost immediately out of it, namely, the relations between Authority and Liberty. And we will begin that consideration, as before, a
11 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
VIII
VIII
He that shall lose his life for My sake shall find it. For what doth it profit a man if he gain the whole world and suffer the loss of his own soul? —MATT. XVI. 25, 26. No recorded word of our Lord better illustrates than does this the startling and paradoxical manner of His teaching. For He Who knew what was in man , Who spoke always down to man's deepest interests, dwelt and spoke therefore in that realm of truth where man's own paradoxical nature is most manifest; where his interests appear t
8 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
IX
IX
Blessed are the meek .—MATT. V. 4. The Kingdom of Heaven suffereth violence, and the violent bear it away .—MATT. XI. 12. We have already considered the Church's relations towards such things as wealth and human influence and power, how she will sometimes use and sometimes disdain them. Let us now penetrate a little deeper and understand the spirit that underlies and explains this varying attitude of hers. I. (i) It has been charged against Christianity in general, and therefore implicitly and s
12 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
X
X
The value, to the worshippers, of the Devotion of the Three Hours' Agony is in proportion to the degree in which they understand that they are watching not so much the tragedy of nineteen hundred years ago as the tragedy of their own lives and times. Merely to dwell on the Death of Christ on Calvary would scarcely avail them more than to study the details of the assassination of Caesar at the foot of Pompey's statue. Such considerations might indeed be interesting, exciting, and even a little in
2 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
THE FIRST WORD
THE FIRST WORD
Father forgive them, for they know not what they do . In previous considerations we have studied the Life of Christ in His Mystical Body from an angle at which the strange and innumerable paradoxes which abound in all forms of life at a certain depth become visible. And we have seen how these paradoxes lie in those strata, so to say, where the Divinity and the Humanity meet. Christ is God and God cannot die; therefore Christ became man in order to be able to do so. The Church is Divine and there
4 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
THE SECOND WORD
THE SECOND WORD
Amen I say to thee, to-day thou shalt be with Me in Paradise. Our Divine Lord, in this Second Word, immediately applies and illustrates the First and drives its lesson home. He shows us how the rain of mercy that poured out of heaven in answer to the prayer He made just now enlightens the man who, above all others present on Calvary, was the most abjectly ignorant of all; the man who, himself at the very heart of the tragedy, understood it less, probably, than the smallest child on the outskirts
5 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
THE THIRD WORD
THE THIRD WORD
Woman, behold thy son. Behold thy mother . Our Divine Lord now turns, from the soul who at one bound has sprung into the front rank, to those two souls who have never left it, and supremely to that Mother on whose soul sin has never yet breathed, on whose breast Incarnate God had rested as inviolate and secure as on the Bosom of the Eternal Father, that Mother who was His Heaven on earth. Standing beside her is the one human being who is least unworthy to be there, now that Joseph has passed to
4 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
THE FOURTH WORD
THE FOURTH WORD
My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me? Our Blessed Lord in the revelation He makes from the Cross passes gradually inwards to Himself Who is its centre. He begins in the outermost circle of all, with the ignorant sinners. He next deals with the one sinner who ceased to be ignorant, and next with those who were always nearest to Himself, and now at last He reveals the deepest secret of all. This is the central Word of the Seven in every sense. There is no need to draw attention to the Paradox
4 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
THE FIFTH WORD
THE FIFTH WORD
I thirst. Our Lord continues to reveal His own condition, since He, after all, is the key to all Humanity. If we understand anything of Him, simultaneously we shall understand ourselves far better. He has shown us that He can truly be deprived of spiritual consolation; and the value of this deprivation; now He shows us the value of bodily deprivation also. And the Paradox for our consideration is that the Source of all can lose all; that the Creator needs His creation; that He Who offers us the
4 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
THE SIXTH WORD
THE SIXTH WORD
It is consummated. He has finished His Father's business , He has dealt with sinners and saints, and has finally disclosed to us the secrets of the Soul and the Body of His that are the hope of both sinners and saints alike. And there is no more for Him to do. An entirely new Beginning, then, is at hand, now that the Last Sabbath is come—the Last Sabbath, so much greater than the First as Redemption is greater than Creation. For Creation is a mere introduction to the Book of Life; it is the arra
5 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
THE SEVENTH WORD
THE SEVENTH WORD
Father, into Thy hands I commend My spirit. He has cried with a loud voice, and the rocks have rent to its echo, and the earth is shaken, and the Veil of the Old Testament is torn from top to bottom as the Old Covenant passes into the New and the enclosed sanctity of the Most Holy Place breaks out into the world. And now, as the level sun shines out again beneath the pall of clouds, He whispers, as at Mary's knee in Nazareth, the old childish prayer and yields up His spirit into His Father's han
3 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
XI
XI
As dying, and behold we live .—II COR. VI. 9. We have considered, so far, a number of paradoxical phenomena exhibited in the life of Catholicism and have attempted to find their reconciliation in the fact that the Catholic Church is at once Human and Divine. In her striving, for example, after a Divine and supernatural Peace, of which she alone possesses the secret, she resists even unto blood all human attempts to supplant this by another. As a human society, again, she avails herself freely of
11 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter