Anarchism And Socialism
Georgii Valentinovich Plekhanov
11 chapters
3 hour read
Selected Chapters
11 chapters
PUBLISHERS' NOTE
PUBLISHERS' NOTE
In reprinting Anarchism and Socialism , by George Plechanoff, we realize that there is not the same need for assailing and exposing anarchism at present as there has been at different times in the past. Yet the book is valuable, not merely because of its historic interest but also to workers coming into contact with the revolutionary movement for the first time. The general conception of anarchism that a beginner often gets is that it is something extremely advanced. It is often expressed somewh
4 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
PREFACE.
PREFACE.
The work of my friend George Plechanoff, "Anarchism and Socialism," was written originally in French. It was then translated into German by Mrs. Bernstein, and issued in pamphlet form by the German Social-Democratic Publishing Office "Vorwärts." It was next translated by myself into English, and so much of the translation as exigencies of space would permit, published in the Weekly Times and Echo . The original French version is now appearing in the Jeunesse Socialiste , and will be issued in bo
3 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
CHAPTER I
CHAPTER I
The French Materialists of the 18th century while waging relentless war against all the " infâmes " whose yoke weighed upon the French of this period, by no means scorned the search after what they called "perfect legislation," i.e. , the best of all possible legislations, such legislation as should secure to "human beings" the greatest sum of happiness, and could be alike applicable to all existing societies, for the simple reason that it was "perfect" and therefore the most "natural." Excursio
14 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
CHAPTER II
CHAPTER II
The great idealistic philosophers of Germany, Schelling and Hegel, understood the insufficiency of the human nature point of view. Hegel, in his "Philosophy of History," makes fun of the Utopian bourgeoisie in search of the best of constitutions. German Idealism conceived history as a process subject to law, and sought the motive-power of the historical movement outside the nature of man . This was a great step towards the truth. But the Idealists saw this motive-power in the absolute idea, in t
9 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
CHAPTER III
CHAPTER III
"I have often been reproached with being the father of Anarchism. This is doing me too great an honour. The father of Anarchism is the immortal Proudhon, who expounded it for the first time in 1848." Thus spoke Peter Kropotkin in his defence before the Correctional Tribunal of Lyons at his trial in January, 1883. As is frequently the case with my amiable compatriot, Kropotkin has here made a statement that is incorrect. For "the first time" Proudhon spoke of Anarchism was in his celebrated book
17 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
CHAPTER IV
CHAPTER IV
If Stirner combats Feuerbach, the "immortal" Proudhon imitates Kant. "What Kant did some sixty years ago for religion, what he did earlier for certainty of certainties; what others before him had attempted to do for happiness or supreme good, the 'Voice of the People' proposes to do for the Government," pompously declares "the father of Anarchism." Let us examine his methods and their results. According to Proudhon, before Kant, the believer and the philosopher moved "by an irresistible impulse,
30 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
CHAPTER V
CHAPTER V
We have seen that in their criticism of the "political constitution," the "fathers" of anarchy always based themselves on the Utopian point of view. Each one of them based his theories upon an abstract principle. Stirner upon that of the "Ego," Proudhon upon that of the "Contract." The reader has also seen that these two "fathers" were individualists of the first water. The influence of Proudhonian individualism was, for a time, very strong in the Romance countries (France, Belgium, Italy, Spain
12 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
CHAPTER VI
CHAPTER VI
We have said that the principal features of Bakounine's programme originated in the simple addition of two abstract principles: that of liberty and that of equality. We now see that the total thus obtained might easily be increased by the addition of a third principle, that of solidarity. Indeed, the programme of the famous "Alliance," adds several others. For example, "The Alliance declares itself Atheist; it desires the abolition of religions, the substitution of science for faith, of human fo
15 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
CHAPTER VII
CHAPTER VII
Among our present-day Anarchists some, like John Mackay, the author of "Die Anarchisten, Kulturgemälde aus dem Ende des xix. Jahrhunderts," declare for individualism, while others—by far the more numerous—call themselves Communists. These are the descendants of Bakounine in the Anarchist movement. They have produced a fairly considerable literature in various languages, and it is they who are making so much noise with the help of the "propaganda by deed." The prophet of this school is the Russia
29 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
CHAPTER VIII
CHAPTER VIII
The Anarchists are Utopians. Their point of view has nothing in common with that of modern scientific Socialism. But there are Utopias and Utopias. The great Utopians of the first half of our century were men of genius; they helped forward social science, which in their time was still entirely Utopian. The Utopians of to-day, the Anarchists, are the abstracters of quintessence, who can only fully draw forth some poor conclusions from certain mummified principles. They have nothing to do with soc
20 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
CHAPTER IX—CONCLUSION
CHAPTER IX—CONCLUSION
The "father of Anarchy," the "immortal" Proudhon, bitterly mocked at those people for whom the revolution consisted of acts of violence, the exchange of blows, the shedding of blood. The descendants of the "father," the modern Anarchists, understand by revolution only this brutally childish method. Everything that is not violence is a betrayal of the cause, a foul compromise with "authority." [79] The scared bourgeoisie does not know what to do against them. In the domain of theory they are abso
6 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter