Historic Doubts Relative To Napoleon Buonaparte
Richard Whately
8 chapters
21 minute read
Selected Chapters
8 chapters
HISTORIC DOUBTS RELATIVE TO NAPOLEON BUONAPARTE.
HISTORIC DOUBTS RELATIVE TO NAPOLEON BUONAPARTE.
Is not the same reason available in theology and in politics?... Will you follow truth but to a certain point?— Burke's Vindication of Natural Society. The first author who stated fairly the connexion between the evidence of testimony and the evidence of experience, was Hume, in his Essay on Miracles ; a work abounding in maxims of great use in the conduct of life.— Edinburgh Review , Sept. 1814, p. 328....
24 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
NEW EDITION.
NEW EDITION.
Several of the readers of this little work (first published in 1819) have derived much amusement from the mistakes of others respecting its nature and object. It has been by some represented as a serious attempt to inculcate universal scepticism; while others have considered it as a jeu d'esprit, &c. [1] The author does not, however, design to entertain his readers with accounts of the mistakes which, have arisen respecting it; because many of them, he is convinced, would be received wit
3 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
POSTSCRIPT TO THE THIRD EDITION.
POSTSCRIPT TO THE THIRD EDITION.
It may seem arrogant for an obscure and nameless individual to claim the glory of having put to death the most formidable of all recorded heroes. But a shadowy champion may be overthrown by a shadowy antagonist. Many a terrific spectre has been laid by the beams of a halfpenny candle. And if I have succeeded in making out, in the foregoing pages, a probable case of suspicion, it must, I think, be admitted, that there is some ground for my present boast, of having killed Napoleon Buonaparte. Let
3 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
POSTSCRIPT TO THE SEVENTH EDITION.
POSTSCRIPT TO THE SEVENTH EDITION.
Since the publication of the Sixth Edition of this work, the French nation, and the world at large, have obtained an additional evidence, to which I hope they will attach as much weight as it deserves, of the reality of the wonderful history I have been treating of. The Great Nation, among the many indications lately given of an heroic zeal like what Homer attributes to his Argive warriors, τίσασθαι ἙΛΈΝΗΣ ὁρμήματά τε στοναχάς τε , have formed and executed the design of bringing home for honoura
1 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
POSTSCRIPT TO THE NINTH EDITION.
POSTSCRIPT TO THE NINTH EDITION.
The Public has been of late much interested and not a little bewildered, by the accounts of many strange events, said to have recently taken place in France and other parts of the Continent. Are these accounts of such a character as to allay, or to strengthen and increase, such doubts as have been suggested in the foregoing pages? We are told that there is now a Napoleon Buonaparte at the head of the government of France. It is not, indeed, asserted that he is the very original Napoleon Buonapar
1 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
POSTSCRIPT TO THE ELEVENTH EDITION.
POSTSCRIPT TO THE ELEVENTH EDITION.
When any dramatic piece takes —as the phrase is—with the Public, it will usually be represented again and again with still-continued applause; and sometimes imitations of it will be produced; so that the same drama in substance will, with occasional slight variations in the plot, and changes of names, long keep possession of the stage. Something like this has taken place with respect to that curious tragi-comedy—the scene of it laid in France—which has engaged the attention of the British public
6 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
INCIDENTS OF TRAVEL—CITY OF MOSCOW.
INCIDENTS OF TRAVEL—CITY OF MOSCOW.
"The circumstances which gave rise to the errors concerning the burning of Moscow, were these:—It is a city of four hundred and fifty thousand inhabitants, in circular form, occupying a large space, five miles across. There the winters are six months long, and the custom was, and still is, to lay up supplies of provisions and wood to last six months of severe cold weather. To prevent these gigantic supplies from encumbering the heart of the city, and yet render them as convenient as practicable
2 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter
POSTSCRIPT.
POSTSCRIPT.
With respect to the foregoing arguments, it has been asserted (though without even any attempt at proof) that they go to prove that the Bible-narratives contain nothing more miraculous than the received accounts of Napoleon Buonapartè. And this is indeed true, if we use the word " miraculous " in the very unusual sense in which Hume (as is pointed out in the foregoing pages) has employed it; to signify simply " improbable ;" an abuse of language on which his argument mainly depends. It is indeed
1 minute read
Read Chapter
Read Chapter